Why You… Y Me? – Series Review & Episode Guide

Namwah is a university student who loves BL. Accompanied by her best friend Kanoon, they are obsessed with shipping an imaginary couple. Copter is a celebrity heartthrob, while Maitoon is an online personality specializing in cafe art. Although these two guys have never interacted, their supporters like fantasizing about them as a real-life couple. There are fan events for both Copter and Maitoon, which Namwah attends regularly. She joins the adoring crowd of fangirls to cheer on her favourite idol.

Namwah runs a small fan account that keeps track of Copter and Maitoon updates. Her rival, Star, runs a more prominent account with a larger fan following. Although they support the same people, the two fangirls don't get along. They often clash at fan events. As an influential fan, Star tends to receive more privileges, which she loves flaunting. Namwah resents her snobby competitor and wants to one-up her. Unfortunately, she hasn't succeeded so far.

During class, Namwah meets Gap and pairs up with him for a school project. Initially, they have a lousy first impression of each other. Namwah bumps into Gap and spills his drink over him. However, they overcome their differences and become on friendly terms. Namewah takes Gap to a fan meeting for Maipai, introducing him to her favourite hobby. He seems embarrassed to stand among the crowd of screaming fangirls.

Namwah's brother Shogun is a famous music producer. He runs a large music studio at his home. When Gap reveals he has a band, Namwah invites him to practice at her place for free. The band is called Evening Sunday and consists of five members. They include Gap (vocalist), Maitoh (drummer), Green (bassist), Nice (keyboardist), and Ford (guitarist). In addition, Paul is the band's manager. After meeting everyone, Namwah observes several suggestive interactions between the guys. Maitoh and Green seem chummy. So are Nice and Paul.

Gap's band is competing in a music competition. They want to meet Namwah's brother and seek his counsel. However, Namwah hesitates to introduce her new friends to her stern brother. Gap tries befriending her by offering VIP tickets for a Copter event. He also lies about being a BL fanboy to get into her good graces. As they become closer, Gap enjoys the perks that his friendship with Namwah brings. She's enthusiastic about Evening Sunday and wants to promote the band. However, Gap feels guilty about deceiving Namwah, especially since he isn't a real BL fan.

Why You… Y Me? is a cheerful BL series packed with enthusiasm. Each episode contains a brisk pace, quirky humour, and lively energy. The characters like to be playful, making lighthearted jokes and cute mischief. There are also some serious storylines, although the carefree plot never feels too heavy. The silliness stands out more prominently and eclipses the few attempts at creating tension in the narrative. Why You… Y Me? comes across as slightly frivolous, unable to transition from a childish comedy into a mature drama.

In Why You… Y Me?, the protagonist is a BL fangirl. She gets excited when two guys come together, and her giddy fantasies contribute to the humourous scenarios. The series focuses on yaoi culture, highlighting how some fans cross the line and become obsessive. It clearly communicates that stalking celebrities and invading their privacy is the wrong thing to do. While I appreciate the messages, the story simply isn't that complex. It doesn't make bold statements or profound revelations that impact me significantly. Why You… Y Me could've gone deeper into expanding its themes.

Why You… Y Me? fetishizes gay men more than your typical BL drama. Namwah's yaoi fandom is played for laughs, but some of her behaviour makes me uncomfortable. When Namwah sees two guys in an intimate moment, she immediately points a camera at them. That's rude and invasive. Later, Namwah uploads the pictures as publicity tools for the band, which feels icky. I dislike how she treats their sexuality as a public spectacle for entertainment. With that said, I'm not overly outraged. I still like Namwah, who carries the series with her sweet, charming personality.

However, the other lead is sleazy. Gap pretends to be a yaoi fanboy to impress Namwah. While BL is accessible to everyone, the genre appeals primarily to women and the LGBT+ community. Yet, this straight guy misrepresents himself and appropriates a culture in which he has no genuine interest. The optics don't sit right with me. Also, Gap's intentions with Namwah are sketchy. Initially, he gets close to Namwah for her family connections. He then continues lying to her. Their relationship is built on deceit and opportunism. Gap never redeems himself in my eyes.

Although the primary pairing is a BG couple, there are two secondary BL romances. I enjoy Nice & Paul's funny scenes, but the series hardly develops their relationship. They get relegated to comic relief and receive little focus beyond a few amusing exchanges. The other BL storyline is a love triangle, which plays out frustratingly. Maitoh and Shogun look attractive together, yet their bond is shallow. I don't sense a meaningful connection between them. Also, I hate how Maitoh treats Green in Episode 8. Maitoh handles a delicate situation with his friend quite insensitively.

Why You… Y Me? delivers a polished production with bright visuals and a cheerful soundtrack. In addition, both leads (Parn and Jump) are energetic, bringing much youthful exuberance to their roles. The rest of the supporting cast isn't as smooth. A few actors may lack on-camera experience, which you notice in their rookie performances. Overall, I enjoy some aspects of Why You… Y Me? It has a zany story, goofy characters, and good closure for the ending. With that said, this BL drama is too casual and lightweight. I'm left with tepid feelings after finishing a fairly average series.